CyberPath Coaching

CyberPath CoachingCyberPath CoachingCyberPath Coaching
  • Home
  • About
  • Testimonials
  • I Cant Get Any Interviews
  • Choose your path
  • FAQs
  • Resources
  • Cyber Career Corner
  • Succeed In a New Job
  • Glass Cliff Fall Guy
  • Knowing When To Move On
  • Difficult Workplace?
  • Contact
  • More
    • Home
    • About
    • Testimonials
    • I Cant Get Any Interviews
    • Choose your path
    • FAQs
    • Resources
    • Cyber Career Corner
    • Succeed In a New Job
    • Glass Cliff Fall Guy
    • Knowing When To Move On
    • Difficult Workplace?
    • Contact

CyberPath Coaching

CyberPath CoachingCyberPath CoachingCyberPath Coaching
  • Home
  • About
  • Testimonials
  • I Cant Get Any Interviews
  • Choose your path
  • FAQs
  • Resources
  • Cyber Career Corner
  • Succeed In a New Job
  • Glass Cliff Fall Guy
  • Knowing When To Move On
  • Difficult Workplace?
  • Contact

So... You're the Chief Scapegoat Glass Cliff Fall Guy.

You took the job because the company is in trouble. Maybe the breach went public, the forecast got cut, or the last leader left in a hurry. Whatever the cause, the trouble is why the seat was open. Congrats! You have a turnaround job.


Have no illusions about what comes next, because the odds of keeping a turnaround job are low. CEO turnover runs higher in turnaround situations (Schweizer et al., University of Neuchâtel), and even in ordinary conditions, about one in four male CEOs and one in three female CEOs are fired within three years (Russell Reynolds).


The board hired you to signal change. Once that signal has done its work, or the turnaround stalls, the board will start looking for the next one.


You are planning your exit from the minute you accept, and it is the most important plan you will make in the role. If you do it well, you'll protect your reputation and your money.


The seat has an upside, too. A turnaround job makes a strong resume line, and while you hold it you are on a stage with the board, investors, peers and the press all watching. Use that spotlight to build strong connections. People remember the leader who solved hard problems and stayed calm while doing it, and some of them will be the ones who hire you next.


This applies to every leader who takes on a turnaround job, whether the title is CEO, CTO, or CISO.

What else do people call a turnaround job?

 The turnaround job goes by many names, and each one hints at how it tends to end.

  • Poisoned chalice: a prestigious role that is set up to fail.
  • Hospital pass: a rugby term for a pass that arrives just as the tackle lands, so you catch the ball and take the hit.
  • Fall guy: the person positioned to absorb the blame.
  • Scapegoat: the leader who carries the organization's failures out the door.
  • Turnaround hire or rescue hire: the board's own language, which sounds neutral on paper and describes the same seat in practice.
  • Glass cliff: the version researchers have studied most. Michelle Ryan and Alex Haslam named it in 2005 after finding that women were more likely to be appointed to leadership roles when organizations were already struggling (University of Exeter). Russell Reynolds later found that women CEOs are fired at similar rates whether their companies perform well or not (Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance).

Different names, same seat, and the same ending unless you plan for it.

How can you tell you're being set up to take the fall?

Listen to how the job is pitched, because the warning signs usually come straight out of someone's mouth.

  • "How soon can you start?" The urgency may be real, but so is the pressure to get you in the seat before you ask the hard questions.
  • "The last person wasn't the right fit." Ask who held the role before that person, and before them. A seat that keeps emptying has a problem the job description leaves out.
  • "We'll work out the metrics together once you're in." Success will be defined after the fact, by the same people deciding whether you stay.
  • "You'll have the full support of leadership." Ask what that means in budget, headcount, and decision rights. If the answer stays vague, so will the support.
  • "We are SO glad you're here." Relief that loud tells you things are worse than anyone admitted in the interviews, and someone is happy to hand you the problem.

One of these is a reason to dig deeper. Three or more means you already know what kind of job this is.

There Are Two worlds: the one we should have and the one we live in.

There is the world as it should be, and there is the world as it is. Executives get hired, judged, and fired in the second one.


A LinkedIn post made the rounds this week. It listed new CEOs who inherited hard stretches at their companies and closed with sound advice for boards: build diverse pipelines, use consistent criteria, and give new leaders real authority. Every item was right, and none of it will change because someone posted it.


Boards understand the turnaround job, and the pattern persists because it works for the people who run it. If you are the leader being offered the seat, stop waiting for the system to change and plan for the system in front of you.

Why boards do this

Because the system is working as designed.


Hiring a new face during a crisis tells investors, employees and the press that change is coming, with fresh eyes and new ideas. A board under pressure gets real value from that signal.


The same appointment comes with a built-in exit. If the turnaround stalls, the board has someone to blame, and if it works, the board can say thank you and hand the steadier company to a leader who fits the culture it prefers. Either way, the board wins.


The same edge exists below the CEO chair, for the CISO hired the month after a breach or the CTO brought in to rescue a stalled platform migration. I call that seat Chief Scapegoat Glass Cliff Fall Guy.


Execting the system to be fair will not change the outcome, but negotiating your own terms will.

How do you take a turnaround job with your eyes open?

 Walk in clear-eyed and plan accordingly, starting with these eight moves.

  1. Expect the honeymoon in overdrive. The welcome will be louder than usual, so enjoy it and bank none of it.
  2. Build your network on day one, inside and outside. The internal network helps you deliver. The external one is your next job, and you will need one sooner than the offer letter suggests.
  3. Pick a few wins you can finish. Two or three visible changes become the core of your story in the next interview.
  4. Take nothing personally. That includes the praise.
  5. Judge people by what they do under pressure. The warmest welcome can come from the person best positioned to benefit from your exit.
  6. Document everything. Record your decisions, the warnings you raised, and the resources you asked for and did not get. If the story gets rewritten later, your records are the original.
  7. Negotiate your exit before you need it. Severance, equity treatment, indemnification, and D&O coverage belong in the offer. The company wants you most before you sign, which is when it says yes most easily.
  8. Protect your head. The seat is a role you hold, so keep it from becoming how you see yourself.

Each of these has a how, and it depends on your seat, your board, and your leverage. 

Offered a turnaround job, or already in one?

Maybe you are weighing an offer for a turnaround job. Maybe you already took one and are only now seeing what you walked into. 


Either way, talk to us. In a confidential conversation, we will help you see where you stand and decide what to do next, whether that means negotiating before you sign or planning your next move from inside the seat.

Sources

  • Ryan & Haslam, glass cliff research summary: University of Exeter, REF Impact Case Study
  • Russell Reynolds: Why Women CEOs Leave Sooner (May 2025)
  • Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance, same report (June 2025)
  • Schweizer et al., Why Outsider CEOs Bring Less Change, University of Neuchâtel

Let's CONNECT FOR A CONFIDENTIAL CONVERSATION

Schedule a complimentary call
  • About
  • Testimonials
  • I Cant Get Any Interviews
  • Choose your path
  • Cyber Career Coaching
  • FAQs
  • Resources
  • Cyber Career Corner
  • Succeed In a New Job
  • Glass Cliff Fall Guy
  • Office Politics
  • Knowing When To Move On
  • H1B Impact on Cyber Jobs
  • Exit Interview Yes or No
  • My Resume Gets Rejected
  • Resume Rejection Fix
  • How to beat ATS
  • How to become a CISO
  • How to become a CISO Pt 2
  • Interview Prep
  • Your Resume
  • STARL Interview Technique
  • Cyber Interview Guide
  • Before you even apply
  • Bad Work History Check
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Terms of Service

Copyright © 2024 CyberPath Coaching - All Rights Reserved.

 cyberpath coaching is powered by resilienttech advisors.

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

DeclineAccept